A pair of goals by Marymount with 9:17 and 8:58 left in the third quarter gave the Saints a 7-5 lead, but Etown struck back with an extra man goal by Allen Churchman (Aston, PA/Garnet Valley) that was assisted by Sean Thomson (Malvern, PA/Great Valley) at 6:50. Churchman struck again, this time on an assist by Adam Whitaker (Havertown, PA/Haverford) at 5:41 to even the score at 7-7. The stalemate was short lived, though, as Marymount's Brandon Sallee (Westchester, OH/Moeller) scored just 31 seconds later to give the Saints an 8-7 lead going into the fourth quarter. Marymount scored again at 8:18 and 2:53 remaining in the fourth quarter to go up 10-7, but the Blue Jays struck back with an unassisted extra man goal by Churchman, his fourth goal of the game, with 1:42 remaining. A goal at 1:13 by Marymount's Jim Hoagland (Blue Bell, PA/LaSalle Prep.) put the game away.

Churchman led Etown with four goals scored. Matt Newell (Malvern, PA/Great Valley) scored a pair of goals, and Smetana had one goal and one assist. Thomson scored one goal and had three assists for the Blue Jays, and Whitaker posted one assist. Etown goalie Chris Swierczek (Media, PA/Penncrest) played the first half and made 13 saves, while Brian Burke (Upper Darby, PA/Haverford) played the second half and had nine saves. The Blue Jays made good use of their extra man opportunities, scoring three goals on five Marymount penalties. Marymount had just one extra man goal on five Etown penalties.