Look buddy. O'hara may have better stick skills but defensively Timms is way better. He's 6'5, O'hara is like what 5'10. They're two completely different players, O'hara has better stick skills and runs the field better. But, if I were to pick one to play defense for me it would be timms, he wasnt to shabby his sophmore yr with 28 caused turnovers.